Review: Van Halen’s “A Different Kind Of Truth”
Posted in My Big, Black Cock., Reviews: Scott Crawford on February 8th, 2012 by Scott CrawfordReview I just wrote as I listened to the whole album, to be posted on mybigblackcock.com in about a minute:
It’s been an endurance test to get through this. Very frustrating listen, because all 3 Van Halen boys sound fantastic (despite the production, which really tries to make loud, fast, hard, heavy rock n’ roll music sound “adult contemporary”) and no one wanted this to be a big win for David Lee Roth more than I did, but really I think it took them too long to get their shit together, if it’s even together now. Dave, bless ‘em, just doesn’t sound up to the task anymore on at least the first half of the album, he sounds shoehorned into most of the songs, and there’s little to nothing to sing along to here until about two-thirds through the record. To me, that’s just not Van Fucking Halen.
Again, no knock on the musicianship overall: Alex, Ed and Wolfie (huge improvement over Mike Anthony, sorry, purists) sound stellar here, which is going to cover a multitude of sins for most people, but damn it, I know what the good stuff sounds like and I’m not fooled by most of this. As far as Dave’s output goes, this isn’t “Your Filthy Little Mouth” good on a song for song basis (granted, I still think that’s an underrated record), and I’m not entirely sure whose fault that is. Might be that Dave couldn’t get it done, might be that the rest of the band and the producer wouldn’t get out of his way, but whatever the case was, the end results are a mixed bag at best.
If you want some highlights, “Big River” (the best of the bunch), “Beats Workin’”, “Outta Space” and “Honeybabysweetiedoll” are as good at it gets here, and the only ones that REALLY sound like actual Van Halen songs out of those are “Big River” and “Beats Workin’” (tracks 12 and 13 out of 13; yeah, the album finishes strong, but that’s still a long time to wait for the goods if you’re listening to a whole album). “Stay Frosty” is as downright embarrassing (“Hey, it’s an “Ice Cream Man” sequel!” is no way to live, man) as the first single, “Tattoo” was. The rest of what I didn’t name is great instrumentally, but cluttered and lukewarm vocally and from a songwriting perspective.
So, yeah, not as blown away by this as the rest of my fellow old farts seem to be this week.



